A letter to Optimization comminuty from 2023 on publication culture
This letter was signed by members of optimization community in 2023. It was circulated via SIAG/OPT mailing list. We find it relevant and useful to repost this letter now. The letter below was created and circulated more than 3 years ago. No one foresaw the effect that the recent advances of AI would have on our field and the publication process. However, the letter clearly identifies problems that already existed at the time—namely, the misalignment between our community’s research values and commonly used metrics. This misalignment is partially responsible for the crisis that our publication and research culture faces today. In the near future, we hope to engage in discussions about the best practices we want to uphold. Active members of MOS will be able to contribute posts to these discussions. For now, I would simply like to repost the letter for anyone who may find it useful. Dear members of the optimization community, The purpose of this open letter is to bring attention to the recent change in the publication culture and to propose action in order to correct what we deem as undesirable effects of that change. It has become apparent that in the last one or two decades we have been seeing a substantial increase in the number of papers, both posted online and submitted to conferences and journals. The easy visibility of published and posted work, as well as easily accessible online metrics, such as Google Scholar, put pressure on the researchers (especially junior ones) to compete in terms of quantity. More importantly, this pressure is supported by the evaluation processes for hiring and promotion in academia and research labs as well as within funding agencies. What is clearly lagging is a thorough review process, as reviewers find themselves lacking time and incentive to read papers in depth. On the other hand, we strongly believe that careful, thorough, and timely reviews are essential to the overall quality of the publication process and in advancing the field. They are very time-consuming and require expertise, yet they are hardly ever rewarded. While, ideally, reviewing can be intellectually rewarding, more recognition and encouragement is needed. Otherwise, it takes low priority compared to other more explicitly rewarded or required activities – publications, teaching, student supervision, etc. The journal Mathematical Programming has recently introduced a system of "scoring" reviewers, and these scores are used to recognize meritorious reviewers. In time we expect other journals to introduce similar processes for recognizing review efforts. However, such recognition should be more widespread and further acknowledged by the community, for it to have a bearing on the person's career advancement. As journal editors and research supervisors, we are in a position to comment on applicants' contributions as reviewers in promotion or recommendation letters. Additionally, as evaluators, we should seek such evaluations from other letter writers. This evaluation metric should not only include the mere fact of serving as a reviewer or an editor for particular journals but should instead comment on the quality of the contribution. The exact evaluation and acknowledgment process is subject to further careful consideration to ensure a balance of quality vs. quantity. With this letter, we seek to encourage the community to contribute to the process and to start paying attention to the reviewers' roles in the advancement of research. We plan to continue the discussion of the exact mechanisms that will be most effective in achieving the goals stated in this letter and implement these mechanisms as soon as it is practicable. Miguel Anjos, University of Edinburgh Alper Atamturk, UC Berkeley Necdet Serhat Aybat, Penn State Amitabh Basu, Johns Hopkins Radu Ioan Bot, University of Vienna Nicolas Boumal, EPFL Samuel Burer, University of Iowa James Burke, University of Washington Coralia Cartis, Oxford Jonathan Eckstein, Rutgers Robert Freund, MIT Michael P. Friedlander, University of British Columbia Rui Gao, UT Austin Serge Gratton, Univ. Toulouse Tim Hoheisel, McGill Fatma Kilinc-Karzan, Carnegie Mellon Simge Kucukyavuz, Northwestern Daniel Kuhn, EPFL George Lan, Georgia Tech Jeff Linderoth, University of Wisconsin-Madison Andrea Lodi, Cornell Tech Jim Luedtke, University of Wisconsin-Madison Boris Mordukhovich, Wayne State David Morton, Northwestern Giacomo Nannicini, USC Sebastian Pokutta, ZIB and TUB Jong Shi Pang, USC Daniel Ralph, University of Cambridge Daniel P. Robinson, Lehigh University Johannes Royset, Naval Postgraduate School Andrzej Ruszczynski, Rutgers University Katya Scheinberg, Cornell Uday V. Shanbhag, Penn State University Anthony Man-Cho So, CUHK Mikhail Solodov, IMPA Akiko Takeda, The University of Tokyo Kim-Chuan Toh, National University of Singapore Levent Tunçel, University of Waterloo Luis Nunes Vicente, Lehigh Andreas Wächter, Northwestern University Wolfram Wiesemann, Imperial College Stefan Wild, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Zaiwen Wen, Peking University Lin Xiao, FAIR at Meta Yangyang Xu, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Jane Ye, University of Victoria Frank E. Curtis, Lehigh Jiawang Nie, UCSD Oktay Gunluk, Cornell Xiaojun Chen, PolyU HK Sanjeeb Dash, IBM Research Wotao Yin, Alibaba DAMO Academy